Wed 28 May 2008
Death Cab for Cutie - Narrow Stairs & Augustana - Can’t Love, Can’t Hurt
Posted by BJ Sintay under CDs, Music, Reviews
No Comments
I listen to a ton of music, so when hot young groups (especially) put out second albums I take note. The sophomore release is bound to either make or break a band. Two recent selections (among many!) are the popular Augustana and Death Cab for Cutie releases which I purchased from Amazon.com’s MP3 store.
Augustana’s new release “Can’t Love, Can’t Hurt” features the same lovable melodies from the first album - minus the hit song (remember “Boston”?). In my opinion, the songs have all of the right ingredients for a great pop rock album. The problem is that they seem to just be that: ingredients. I found that the album lacked the big passionate moments from “Stars and Boulevards” that made the former release come together as a massive hit. The combo has a nice melding of deep hooks, raspy vocals, and expansive melodies, but I am left expecting a bit more. A few of the songs such as “Hey Now” and “Twenty Years” show some depth but are offset by extensive low moments that are repetitive and tired. This album only lasted a week or so in my regular lineup before I moved on. Maybe time will bring it back around.
Another highly anticipated album for 2008 is Death Cab for Cutie’s “Narrow Stairs”. Three years in the making, Death Cab’s progressive feel is clear. But much like Augustana, I feel that most of the songs on this album lack passion
when compared to the first major label release “Plans”. This album definitely has some high moments such as the remarkable song “I Will Possess Your Heart”, a song that easily sticks. That is the kind of stuff that made “Plans” so good. Unfortunately, most of the soul stops there.
In my opinion, the rest of this album is forced and shallow. In a time where bands like Wilco are revolutionizing the soundscape for mellow, simple albums, “Narrow Stairs” seems to fall into a completely different league - the minors. On the flip side, I think this album will be a helpful progression for the group as they venture further from their semi-emo sounds. Still, the tracks are stale. If you’re not a huge Death Cab fan, save the bucks and buy the hit single instead of the full album.
I know I’m a bit late in reviewing Death Cab for Cutie’s 2005 debut (non-indie) album, but I’ve just recently discovered this great disk. Plans is an excellent emo-ish rock album performed by a seasoned group of musicians. My favorite tracks include “What Sarah Said,” “Summer Skin,” and “Soul Meets Body.” I like many of the songs on this album because of their experimental nature. The album is generally mellow and smooth, emitting an emotional overtone. The production is crisp and clear.
